Return to the text: What This Adds Up To
The Krebs Cycle Machines
The assumptions
- Chain lengths are for E. coli, the standard bacterial reference (UniProt): step 1 citrate synthase 427; step 2 aconitase B 865; step 3 isocitrate dehydrogenase 416; step 4 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase complex 933 + 405 + 474; step 5 succinyl-CoA synthetase 289 + 388; step 6 succinate dehydrogenase 588 + 238 + 129 + 115; step 7 fumarase C 467; step 8 malate dehydrogenase 312.
- Each different chain is counted once. Real machines often use several copies (citrate synthase works as a team of six).
- Atoms per amino acid, once built into a chain: from 7 (glycine) to 24 (tryptophan); about 15.6 on average, weighting each amino acid by how often it occurs in proteins.
- The molecule being worked on: about 20 atoms (citrate, the largest, is 21).
- The generous rule from Counting Protein Chains: at every position, any of 10 of the 20 amino acids will do, so a chain of n positions is a target of 1 in 2n.
- Drums = digits in the count.
Step 1: total size of the cycle
427 + 865 + 416 + (933 + 405 + 474) + (289 + 388) + (588 + 238 + 129 + 115) + 467 + 312 = 6,046 amino acids
Fourteen different chains, about six thousand amino acids.
Step 2: atoms, against the working molecule
Citrate synthase: 427 × 15.6 ≈ 6,700 atoms; 6,700 ÷ 20 ≈ 330 to 1
Malate dehydrogenase (smallest machine): 312 × 15.6 ≈ 4,900 atoms; 4,900 ÷ 20 ≈ 245 to 1
Citrate synthase working unit (6 copies): 6 × 6,700 ≈ 40,000 atoms
Step 3: targets under the generous rule
One 300-long protein: 2300 ≈ 2 × 1090 → 90 drums (the figure used throughout the book)
Citrate synthase: 2427 ≈ 3.5 × 10128 → 129 drums
Smallest machine, step 8: 2312 ≈ 8.3 × 1093 → 94 drums
All fourteen chains together: 26,046 ≈ 101,820 → 1,821 drums
Step 4: against the tries available
From Every Bacterium a Computer: every bacterium that ever lived, making a new chain every twenty minutes for 3.5 billion years, makes about 45 drums of tries. From Real Matter: all usable matter in the universe as computers, for the age of the universe, makes 78 drums.
Found one machine at a time, the tries add rather than multiply, but each of the eight machines on its own (the smallest at 94 drums) is beyond both figures. Found all together, the target is 1,821 drums.
(Some single chains inside the multi-chain machines are short — the smallest, at step 6, is 115 amino acids, 35 drums — but a chain on its own is not a working machine.)
Last revised 2026-11-18
Return to the text: What This Adds Up To