Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 7: Junk DNA and a Demolition Tool

← Lenski's BacteriaA Lethal Tool →

Not What the Standard Model Needs

Both of these cases matter — they show, beyond any doubt, that small genetic changes happen, that they can be beneficial, and that one can build on another over time. But neither one is actually an example of what the Standard Model needs.

The stickleback case was a regulatory switch being flipped. The Lenski case was a switch being flipped too, in the end, by way of a duplication — an existing stretch of DNA copied and relocated, not a single letter changed. Both belong to newly discovered, faster classes of evolutionary tools — sometimes called "toolkit" mechanisms — that a later chapter will discuss on their own terms.

What concerns this chapter is something narrower and, in a sense, more fundamental: the ordinary single-letter point mutation, accumulating gradually, the way the Standard Model has always described it. And there are two distinct places such a change could, in principle, do its work. It could occur within an existing, already-functional gene, gradually converting it into something new. Or it could occur out in junk DNA, gradually building a new gene where none existed before.

The two raise some very different problems, and they deserve to be taken up one at a time. This chapter will start with the first: what happens when point mutations accumulate inside a gene that already does something, and whether that accumulation can plausibly turn it into something else. The second — point mutations building something new out of non-coding DNA — will wait for the next chapter.

Last revised 2026-11-19

← Lenski's BacteriaA Lethal Tool →