Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue?

← When Could Any of This Have Happened?From One Cell to Trillions →

Chickens and Eggs

So, in the end, there are no good answers for how life got to where it is. Nobody has a demonstrated account of how something this coordinated could have arisen fully formed, all at once, and nobody has a demonstrated account of how it could have been built up step by step either, given what even the simplest living things we can examine today actually require. How a genetic code arises. How that code becomes a shared, universal language, spoken identically by every living thing on Earth. And any number of other questions cut from the same cloth.

What's unfortunate is how rarely that gap gets reported honestly. The public picture of this whole enterprise tends to be that the big questions are basically settled, with only some fine details still being sorted out — a lab here, a paper there, quietly closing in on the last remaining gaps. It is rare, vanishingly rare, to hear anyone in the field say plainly: this problem may simply not be solvable with what we currently understand, and it might be time to rethink the whole approach.

Don't take my word for any of this. It has never been easier to check for yourself. Just be aware, going in, that the first answer you'll find is usually the most popular one, not the strongest one, and popularity and correctness aren't the same thing. It takes a little more digging — asking whether the evidence for a given claim actually holds up, whether there's real disagreement in the field, whether the confident tone of a headline survives a look at the actual paper underneath it — but with a bit of effort, you'll find that what's been laid out in this chapter isn't a personal opinion. It's a set of well-recognized, openly debated problems, with no good answers yet — and very little acknowledgment of that fact reaching the public at all.

If the arguments in this chapter and in Chapter 5 have torn the RNA World apart, RNA itself can hardly be blamed for it. Tearing things apart, on the evidence laid out here, isn't something RNA is good at.

What we are left with is a bunch of chickens and eggs staring at each other, trying to figure out which came first.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← When Could Any of This Have Happened?From One Cell to Trillions →