Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue?

← A Clever FixJoining RNA Letters →

Making the Letters

Chapter 11 counted what a modern cell spends just on RNA's raw materials. Each letter of RNA is three pieces joined together — a sugar, a phosphate, and a base — and making them takes about twenty-two separate proteins: two whole manufacturing chains for the two families of bases, a branch of the sugar-processing machinery for the sugar, and a few more enzymes to put each letter together. Turning letters into finished, working RNA takes dozens more. And this machinery is essentially universal, found in close to the same form across the whole tree of life — usually a strong sign that a piece of machinery is very old indeed.

None of this modern pathway is available to an RNA World. By definition, protein enzymes don't exist yet in that scenario — RNA is supposed to be the only thing doing any of the work, including, apparently, manufacturing its own raw materials. Which means RNA's own building blocks would have had to arise some other way entirely: through raw, unassisted chemistry on the early Earth, rather than anything resembling the precise, many-step assembly line every living cell relies on today.

And this is where the sugar problem, already met in Chapter 10, comes back with a vengeance. Ribose — the specific sugar RNA is built on — isn't something ordinary early-Earth chemistry hands over cleanly. Left to react on its own, the raw ingredients that could plausibly have been available produce a wide mixture of many different sugars all at once, with ribose making up less than one percent of the result. Some recent work goes further still, suggesting this same reaction may favor branched sugars that RNA can't use at all. There's no known step in ordinary early-Earth chemistry that reaches into that mixture and pulls out just the useful one.

Even granting that ribose somehow turned up in usable form, it then has to be correctly joined to a base — and this step, too, turns out to be stubbornly resistant to easy chemistry. The classic experiments along these lines manage only a small handful of percent yield joining ribose to the purine bases, and the pyrimidine bases don't join to ribose directly at all under the same conditions. Some chemists have since found clever detours, building a letter up piece by piece instead of joining a finished sugar to a finished base. But those routes depend on carefully ordered steps, with purified ingredients added at just the right moments — a chemist's hand at every turn.

So RNA is not a simpler, more readily available alternative to protein and DNA. Building its raw materials requires its own dedicated, multi-step manufacturing chain — one that, in every living cell alive today, is entirely protein-based, with no known RNA machine anywhere in nature performing this job instead. And the one route left over for a genuine, protein-free RNA World — raw early-Earth chemistry — runs into exactly the kind of narrow, low-yield, hard-to-purify problem this book has already met once, with sugar, and meets again here with RNA's own components.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← A Clever FixJoining RNA Letters →