Chapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue?
Where Could This Have Happened?
There's a further complication, and it isn't a separate problem so much as the last one showing up again from a different direction. Recall from Chapter 5 that RNA doesn't sit peacefully in water — its chain breaks down there, and its individual pieces decay there too. Joining two nucleotides together turns out to have exactly the opposite relationship with water: the joining reaction itself releases a water molecule every time it happens, which means an environment already full of water actively resists the reaction, pushing it backward rather than forward. Plain water, in other words, isn't a neutral backdrop for this chemistry. It's an obstacle.
The proposed way around this is to move the whole process somewhere else — a shallow pool at a shoreline, say, that periodically dries out. Removing the water during a dry spell favors joining, and some finished chain can form. But that same pool has to eventually get wet again, whether from rain, tide, or runoff, to bring in fresh material or simply because the cycle repeats — and getting wet again is precisely the condition already established to be RNA's enemy. Researchers who study this directly describe exactly this back-and-forth: some joining happens during the dry phase, some of what was just joined gets undone during the wet phase, and only a slow, hard-won net gain survives cycle after cycle.
Which leaves the RNA World with an uncomfortable choice of address. Building a chain in the first place needs dryness — that's where the joining reaction can actually run forward. But surviving afterward, and doing any useful work, needs water — every proposed function for the RNA World, from folding into a working shape to actually copying itself, has to happen in solution, not in a dried-out film. So the one condition that lets RNA get built is the same condition that would leave it unable to do anything once built, and the one condition it needs in order to function is the same condition that starts taking it back apart. No single environment in this picture serves both needs at once — and the same tension shows up one level down as well, since even the individual pieces of a single letter, the sugar and its base, are joined by that identical kind of water-releasing reaction. The chain and its individual letters share the same vulnerability, at the same address, for the same underlying chemical reason.
Last revised 2026-11-18