Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 13: Shape

← The First EyesChapter 14: Instinct →

How Much Time Was There?

Look at the timing. The first tracks left by anything resembling an arthropod appear about 537 million years ago. Trilobites with calcite-lensed compound eyes appear about 521 million years ago, and Anomalocaris, with some of the sharpest eyes of any animal of its era, by about 515. From the first sign of arthropods to eyes that rival a dragonfly's: something like twenty million years.

Chapter 5 described the Cambrian explosion: nearly every major animal body plan appearing in a window geologists measure at somewhere between ten and twenty-five million years, and the debate over whether molecular evidence pushes some origins earlier. Shape, eyes, and organ placement all belong to that window.

A 2018 study by paleontologists at Oxford and Lausanne made the most thorough search so far, examining every kind of fossil preservation for early arthropods. They found no trace of arthropods before the Cambrian; their evolution, the team concluded, played out within the first thirty to forty million years of it. That cuts both ways. There's no hidden, long Precambrian history for arthropods to fall back on. But by their reading, the arthropods' rise took tens of millions of years, not a single instant.

Eugene Koonin, a leading evolutionary biologist at the US National Institutes of Health, has written about the same pattern across all of life's major transitions, from the first cells to the animal groups. At each one, he wrote, the new kinds of life seem to appear rapidly and fully equipped, and "no intermediate 'grades' or intermediate forms between different types are detectable." His own explanation is that the branching was compressed in time and the traces have eroded. Paleontologist Simon Conway Morris has likewise insisted that the Cambrian explosion is a real event, not an illusion created by gaps in the record. Other mainstream explanations deserve mention too: the earliest animals may have been microscopic and simply too small to fossilize, and molecular clocks suggest some groups originated earlier than their first fossils.

None of this is drawn from advocacy literature. Every claim here comes from mainstream scientists describing what their own field knows and doesn't.

So where does that leave the ear, the body that knows its left from its right, and the trilobite's eye? Not with a calculation; as the opening of this part warned, there's no honest way to price a shape in drums. But with a narrowed question. Some general-purpose parts may be old. The instructions specific to each structure, hundreds of genes and switches for a face alone, could only be tested once that structure existed. And they had to be tuned, for eyes and limbs and guts and shells, across nearly every animal body plan at once, inside a window of some tens of millions of years.

Did chance have a chance? Shape is only the first of the three. The next is instinct: behavior that has to work the first time, with no chance to learn.

Last revised 2026-11-19

← The First EyesChapter 14: Instinct →