Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 6: The Monkeys That Didn't

← Not a ChanceNine Versus One →

Impossible Is Not Very Unlikely

Which leads to a fourth lesson from this episode, and probably the most important one — worth sitting with longer than any single misquote or sloppy phrase. If a statement drawn from a professional mathematician's calculation can leave the impression that near-misses are available on some recognizable timescale, then the intuitive fix suggests itself immediately: just scale up the number of attempts — throw in all the bacteria on Earth, say — and the problem solves itself.

Once you see that impression coming out of an actual calculation by a mathematician, it stops being surprising that people with no calculation in front of them at all find it easy to believe that chance can write the working proteins, and eventually the millions, or by some counts billions, of species that have populated the Earth. Billions of years is a very long time, after all, so anything within reason ought to be able to happen — and nobody's intuition is built to sense the difference between "very large" and "large beyond any comparison that means anything." Without the arithmetic actually done, and done carefully enough to survive being turned into a sentence, "impossible" and "merely very unlikely" feel like the same thing. They are not remotely the same thing.

And the lesson here isn't only about being skeptical of the media, though that's fair too — most outlets ran this story uncritically, quotes and all, and only a few, such as the linguistics blog Language Log, greeted it with the yawn it deserved. It's that even a correct, well-intentioned "no" can smuggle in the same false comfort as an uncritical "yes," if the number behind it never actually gets shown and understood.

Last revised 2026-11-17

← Not a ChanceNine Versus One →