How Universal Is It?
Some form of this cycle turns up in bacteria, in archaea, and in every plant, animal, and fungus examined, and the complete cycle, running the way it runs in us, is found across an enormous range of living things. Many biologists take that as a sign that the cycle, or something very close to it, goes back to very near the beginning of life — though, as we'll see later in this chapter, not everyone agrees on how much of it was there at first.
There are exceptions. A fair number of organisms, many of them living without oxygen — some bacteria, and many archaea, including methane-producing ones — run an incomplete or differently wired version of the cycle. Part of the reason is simple. Running the full cycle the way we run it produces a steady stream of electrons that have to be dumped somewhere, and for most of life today, that somewhere is oxygen. An organism living permanently without oxygen, or anything that can stand in for it, has less use for the full loop, and steps that go unused can, over time, go unmaintained. On that reading, an incomplete cycle isn't a sign of a simpler or more primitive organism. It's an organism doing without something it has no occasion to use — the way a cave-dwelling fish's eyes go unused and stop working, without that making cavefish more ancient than fish that can see.
A small number of other organisms run the cycle in reverse, using it to build organic material out of raw carbon dioxide rather than to extract energy from food. In at least one well-studied case, the reverse-running version turned out to be built from essentially the same set of parts used everywhere else — including the machine at the very first step, long thought to work in one direction only — just run backward, rather than some simpler ancestral stub of the "real" cycle. Interesting exceptions, worth a passing mention, but not ones that change the basic picture. For most of life, in one direction or the other, the world of life runs on this cycle.
Last revised 2026-11-18