Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 8: Weasels

← The Paradox of the LockWhere This Leaves Point Mutation →

Pushback

Of course, there will be pushback against this kind of reasoning, and against the calculations just made. But any real debate on the subject would be premature, because what counts as a plausible response depends on how far these findings generalize. If it turns out that every protein has at least some positions that must be exactly right — failing the moment the wrong amino acid sits there — then any argument that only works in a narrow, special case is a waste of time; the problem would simply be universal. If, on the other hand, the two proteins described in Chapter 7 turn out to be unusual, then a more limited kind of argument becomes possible.

One version of that more limited argument might run as follows: proteins that need a high degree of precision today evolved from earlier proteins that needed much less, and only a handful of additional precise positions had to be added to reach the current, more demanding version. But that argument runs straight into the problem raised in the previous chapter — there are serious difficulties in moving from one already-functional protein to a genuinely different one. The natural next move is to appeal to gene duplication: an extra copy existed, and that spare copy evolved into the new, more precise protein. But as already discussed, duplication that actually leads to a new function appears to be a fairly limited phenomenon — it doesn't happen often enough to serve as a meaningful basis for evolution on a large scale. So this kind of answer could only work if the number of proteins that need a high degree of precision turns out to be relatively small. If it isn't small, some other explanation is needed.

There's another type of response worth considering as well. It's often argued that nothing can be safely concluded from studying "modern" forms of life, because the requirements in ancient times may have been far less exacting than what's observed today. A familiar version of this argument comes up with very large, complex proteins that do essential work in the modern cell: if even relatively small proteins are hard to explain, these vastly larger ones are harder still. The response, in such cases, is to assume — sometimes with supporting evidence, though only in some cases — that the same task was originally carried out by a much smaller, simpler protein, which was gradually replaced over time by the larger modern version. And where there's no actual evidence that a smaller protein could ever have done the job, the usual fallback is simply that once the better version came along, the earlier one disappeared without a trace.

A similar argument could be made here. The precision seen in proteins today, on this view, wasn't necessary in earlier times at all — flexibility was greater, precision was minimal, and the resulting proteins were cruder but still functional. As time went on, evolution had the chance to tinker and refine, slowly, and the high degree of precision seen today is simply the end product of that long process. If that's true, the original version of the protein needed only a handful of precise positions — enough for an early lock — after which evolution kept tinkering until the protein reached its modern, highly precise form. And there's a further wrinkle: some of that slow refining would have had to happen during the short bursts of sudden diversity described in Chapter 5, which leave even less room for a patient, gradual accumulation of precision.

But if that's really what happened, an obvious question follows: why can't the clock be run backward? Why not make changes to a modern protein and trace out what an earlier, cruder version might have looked like? Why do these positions behave as though they're completely immutable now — with any change at all destroying function — if they were once far more forgiving? The standard answer is that everything else in the cell evolved alongside this protein, so the protein can no longer be unwound to its earlier state: the earlier state suited an environment, and other molecules, that no longer exist in their old form either.

Once again, though, there's no concrete evidence that any of this actually happened. It's a story that may or may not be true. What can actually be observed today doesn't support it — and the only real reason to believe it is that believing it is what keeps the whole enterprise standing. There is no other reason.

Last revised 2026-11-19

← The Paradox of the LockWhere This Leaves Point Mutation →