Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 14: Instinct

← A Story About Drifting ContinentsA Different Kind of Program →

How Many Instincts?

Everything so far, the cuckoo, the godwit, the monarch, the compass, is a narrow slice of a much bigger picture, and the size of the picture changes the question.

Chapter 3 settled on a deliberately stingy count: six hundred million species of higher life across the history of the Earth, about one new species a year for six hundred million years. Most of them were animals, and most animals have instincts: what to eat, what to flee, how to court, where to lay eggs, when to move. Beetles alone make the point. About four hundred thousand species have been described so far, and serious estimates of how many actually exist run to well over a million, each living in its own particular way, each presumably needing its own particular instincts to do it.

Instincts don't stay fixed at species boundaries, either. Closely related species share a great deal of instinctive behavior in outline, inherited from a common ancestor, and differ in the details: a different host plant, a different danger, a different courtship display, a different song. If each species has even one instinct of its own that its nearest relatives don't share, the number of distinct instincts life has needed runs to hundreds of millions. Most are small variations on a relative's. But some are wholly new: a new sense, a new compass, a new program like the cuckoo chick's. Each of those needs new equipment, and something like software to run it: specific, calibrated instructions, fitted to a world the genome has never seen.

And it brings the question this part of the book keeps asking. Could any of it have been prepared in advance? The general-purpose parts, yes: the clocks, the light-sensitive molecules, the basic nerve cells. But an instinct to head southwest from Finland and then turn south for Angola is about Finland and Angola. An instinct to throw eggs out of a reed warbler's nest is about reed warblers' nests. Instructions like that can only be tested once the animal, its route, and its world exist, and each new species needs its own. That's the scale of the question this chapter has only begun to open.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← A Story About Drifting ContinentsA Different Kind of Program →