A Story About Drifting Continents
Many years ago, I asked an evolutionary biologist how the New Zealand long-tailed cuckoo could ever have come to make its journey: a young bird, alone, setting out across thousands of kilometers of open Pacific with no coastline, no landmark, and, this is the part worth sitting with, no reason ever to have attempted it in the first place. His answer was continental drift. New Zealand and the islands where the cuckoo winters, he said, must once have sat much closer together and drifted apart over millions of years, with the migration simply stretching to keep pace as the gap widened.
I didn't know enough geology at the time to question it, so I let it go. It's a tidy answer, and it would dissolve the whole mystery if it were true. It isn't.
New Zealand is the exposed tip of a mostly sunken landmass that began breaking away from Australia and Antarctica about eighty-five million years ago, and it has sat out in the South Pacific ever since. The islands the cuckoo winters on aren't drifted fragments of anything. Nearly all of them are volcanoes, built one at a time out of the open ocean floor, many as the Pacific seafloor crept over fixed hot spots deep in the Earth. Many are only a few million years old, far younger than New Zealand's isolation. There was never a version of the map with New Zealand sitting next to them.
A fair reply is that the tropical Pacific has always had islands of some kind, old ones slowly sinking as new ones rise. True, but that only means there were always places to go, not that they were ever close. The young bird has always had the same kind of empty ocean to cross.
So the question stands. What could have started the first birds on such a trip, gradually or otherwise, when nothing visible pulled them toward those islands, nothing told them anything was there, and a bird flying blind over that much open water would be expected simply to die at sea?
Nobody fully knows. There is a real proposal in the scientific literature: that birds occasionally blown off course, or flying a mistaken heading, sometimes find new land, and that their success can set a population on a new route. But it's built to explain small shifts in birds that already migrate, that already know how to fatten up, time the trip, and hold a heading. It doesn't explain how the urge, the fuel, and the navigation to cross thousands of kilometers of open ocean appeared in the first place. Applied to a case like this, it moves the question rather than answering it.
Last revised 2026-11-18