Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 14: Instinct

← Steering by the SunA Story About Drifting Continents →

Stumbled On, or Handed Down?

The ability to steer by the sun, correcting continuously for its movement across the sky, doesn't belong to birds and butterflies alone. It has been shown in bees, in ants, some of which use it to find their way home across open desert with no landmarks, in hoverflies, in fish, in sea turtles, in lizards, and in small beach-dwelling crustaceans called sandhoppers, which can do it by the moon as well.

That's a long and scattered guest list for one very particular trick. So which is it: one ancient ability, invented once and carried down into all its descendants, or the same trick found separately, over and over, by animals with no recent history in common?

Part of the answer is clear, and it deserves saying. Some of the parts are very old. Internal clocks that keep a roughly twenty-four-hour rhythm are found in nearly all life, down to some bacteria. Light-sensitive molecules are older than animals. These are exactly the kind of general-purpose parts that the opening of this part of the book said could be prepared in advance, and they were.

But the parts aren't the compass. The machinery that combines clock and sun into a heading isn't the same from one animal to another. In the monarch, the clock that matters sits in the antennae; nothing like that arrangement exists in birds. If the ability is one continuous inheritance, the machinery carrying it out has been rebuilt more than once, from different parts. And insects and vertebrates last shared an ancestor something like six or seven hundred million years ago, a small, simple animal with, as far as anyone knows, nothing that could do this kind of calculation. So if the compass were inherited from that ancestor, it would have to have worked in an animal with almost no nervous system to work it.

Suppose instead it was found separately, again and again. Biologists call this convergent evolution, and it's real and well documented: eyes, flight, and echolocation have each arisen more than once. But naming a pattern isn't explaining it. "Convergent evolution" says that unrelated lineages arrived at the same answer independently. It doesn't say how blind variation managed it. Selection can't do the inventing; it can only keep or discard what variation hands it. A working sun compass needs several things to come together at once: a clock, a way of reading the sun, a way of combining the two, and a link from the result to the muscles that steer. If the number of ways to fail at that is vast, and it should be, then chance finding the same small target over and over, in animals separated by hundreds of millions of years, isn't made any less remarkable by having a name.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← Steering by the SunA Story About Drifting Continents →