Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 13: Shape

← Not Just DecorationWhich Side Is Which →

Old Parts, New Jobs

It would make a tidier story if everything higher life needs turned out to be brand new, arriving all at once, right on cue. The evidence doesn't allow so tidy a story, and the messier picture is more interesting.

Take the ability of cells to stick to the right neighbors, a basic requirement for any organized tissue. A tissue that can't hold itself together, or lets its cells wander off and mix with the wrong kind, isn't a tissue in any useful sense. The molecules responsible, called cadherins, turn out to be old. They're found in the simplest animals, and also in the single-celled organisms that are animals' closest living relatives, which means they predate animals altogether. Whatever they were doing before, helping single cells cling together in loose colonies perhaps, or catch prey, they were already there long before any body needed them.

The same goes for some of the master genes that lay out a body plan: which end is the head, where limbs go. Many of them were already present in the common ancestor of most animals, which, on molecular evidence, lived before the Cambrian.

So part of the toolkit wasn't invented on the spot. It was old material pressed into new service. But "pressed into new service" is doing a lot of quiet work in that sentence. An old molecule doesn't automatically know how to do a harder job just because it's been around a long time. Turning a simple stick-together molecule into something that sorts cells into layers, draws sharp boundaries between tissues, and coordinates movement takes new partner molecules, working alongside the old one, doing jobs it was never built for. That's a merger, an old core part paired with new machinery, and the new machinery faces exactly the same question as anything else that's new.

And here the limit described in the opening of this part of the book applies with full force. The master genes are general-purpose: they say "head end here," "limb here." They aren't the shape. The hundreds of genes that shape a face, and the switches that set exactly how much each one is used, are tuned to this particular face. That layer of instructions can't be tested, and so can't be improved by selection, until there's a face for it to shape. The general-purpose parts could be old. The specific instructions had to come with the body.

Two examples from the very beginning of animal life show what that means in practice.

Last revised 2026-11-19

← Not Just DecorationWhich Side Is Which →