Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 13: Shape

← Old Parts, New JobsThe First Eyes →

Which Side Is Which

Every animal with real internal organs faces a problem a simple, symmetrical creature never has to solve: deciding which side is which, and getting every organ to agree. In people, the heart sits to the left, the liver to the right; the right lung has three lobes and the left has two; the gut loops the same way in nearly everyone.

What happens when the system misfires is revealing. A small number of people are born with everything reversed, a perfect mirror image. That's usually harmless: every organ is on the "wrong" side, but they all agree, so everything still fits together. The dangerous version is when the organs don't agree, some following one plan and some the other. That mixed-up arrangement brings serious heart defects. What matters isn't left or right as such. It's that every organ gets the same answer.

In mice, the mechanism is genuinely elegant. Very early, before the embryo shows any visible difference between its sides, a small pit forms, lined with tiny hairlike cilia. The cilia all tilt the same way and spin together, which turns their spinning into one steady current sweeping fluid toward the left. That one-sided current switches on a particular signal, a gene called Nodal, on the left side only, and the signal cascades outward, telling each organ which side it's on. Fish and frogs do much the same.

But not every vertebrate does. Chicks and pigs have no such spinning cilia and no space for a current to flow, yet they still end up with Nodal switched on at the left, and their organs placed correctly. How they make the first decision is, according to the researchers studying it, still largely a mystery. Snails and fruit flies use yet another method: a twist built into the cells themselves. The first step differs from animal to animal. What comes after it is much the same.

That cuts two ways, and both are worth saying. On one side, a one-sided Nodal signal turns up in animals as simple as sea urchin larvae, so a basic way of telling left from right may be old, older than the organs it now places. That part may have been prepared in advance.

On the other side, look at what wasn't. Telling a cell "you're on the left" accomplishes nothing by itself. Each organ needs its own instructions for what to do with that information: which way the heart loops, which lung gets three lobes, which way the gut turns. Those responses are specific to each organ, and they could only be tested once the organ existed. And they all have to agree, because a mixed-up answer is the dangerous one. Meanwhile, some lineages swapped out the first step entirely, replacing one way of deciding with another, and every one of them had to go on getting the same answer, every generation, throughout the change.

Last revised 2026-11-19

← Old Parts, New JobsThe First Eyes →