Chapter 17: What You Have to Believe
If Not Chance, Then What?
Physicists met a version of this problem a few decades ago, coming from the other direction. As they measured the constants that govern the universe more precisely — the strengths of its forces, the masses of its particles — some of them noticed something startling. Values that could, as far as anyone knew, have been almost anything turned out to sit inside the narrow ranges that allow stars, chemistry, and eventually life to exist at all. Fred Hoyle, the astronomer who worked out how stars make carbon, put his reaction memorably: it looked as though "a superintellect has monkeyed with physics." Enough physicists took the problem seriously that it became a live question in the field: perhaps a universe tuned this finely is not something chance alone should be expected to produce.
One answer many of them reached for is the multiverse: countless universes with every possible setting, ours simply one of the few where someone can exist to notice. We've seen why that explains nothing. But the physicists' experience shows something else as well. It's one thing to doubt that chance did the job. It's another to know what to do with that doubt — what to put in chance's place.
A reader who has spent a lifetime assuming chance explains biology may now be standing exactly where those physicists stood. If chance doesn't have the power this book has shown it lacks, the next question can't be avoided, uncomfortable as it is: then what does explain it? How did I come to exist, and why?
For what it's worth, here is how it looks to me, and it is only a guess. What the physicists found suggests a universe that began with its rules already set — rules under which stars form and chemistry happens, without anyone arranging each star by hand. I see no reason to suppose life had to work any differently in that respect. The whole system, from its molecules up to its grand pattern, looks to me like planned work, not something that just happened.
But the rules science has found so far can't be the whole story; that's what the arithmetic in this book has shown. Whatever set things up would have to include more than those rules. Perhaps there are deeper rules not yet discovered. Perhaps the conditions were set so that life would develop in a certain direction — the way the asteroid that struck the Earth sixty-six million years ago ended the age of the dinosaurs and opened the way for mammals. Perhaps there were nudges along the way, at the points where the gaps are widest. I don't know which, and I don't know how to say it more precisely. Evolution may well be part of the answer: under the right conditions, it may have done a good deal. But there seems to be a great deal of cleverness in the setup, and a great many points where something more than chance may have been needed.
This book isn't going to try to settle that, beyond offering that guess, labeled as a guess. It isn't the right place, and I'm not the right person. What stands behind the numbers in these pages is something each reader has to work out, in their own way and for their own reasons. That isn't a dodge. It's simply beyond what a book like this can honestly claim to answer.
Last revised 2026-11-19