Chapter 17: What You Have to Believe
Saying "I Don't Know"
There is one more reply, and it's the most natural of all: "What's the alternative? We're here. It had to have happened somehow."
As a starting point for research, I have no quarrel with that. A scientist who says, "Life exists, so let's find out how it could have arisen naturally," is doing what scientists do, and may well learn something along the way. My quarrel is with how the results are reported.
It's one thing to say "we don't know." It's something entirely different to say "we know" when you don't. The first is honest, and science has said it many times on the way to its greatest discoveries. The second is where the trouble starts. And, as we saw, "we'll figure it out eventually" doesn't help: it's a promise, not a finding.
Consider how we treat the same thing elsewhere. A company is quietly sliding toward bankruptcy. If its chief executive publishes statements assuring investors that all is well, we don't call that optimism. We call it a crime, and people go to prison for it. The reasoning is simple: people made serious decisions based on what they were told, and what they were told wasn't true.
Now consider a field that tells the public its central question is settled, when the evidence shows something closer to a deep, unsolved problem. People make decisions based on that too — some of the most basic decisions a person makes, about what they are and why they're here. Much of the research is paid for with public money, through government grants, on the strength of claims that are half true, or less. I'm not suggesting anyone be hauled into court. But it's fair to ask why misrepresenting a balance sheet is treated as a serious wrong, and misrepresenting the state of our knowledge about where we came from isn't treated as anything at all.
It's made worse when the people who point out the gap are treated as cranks rather than answered. A field confident in its evidence welcomes the hard questions, because it can answer them. Stating that the answers are in hand when they aren't, and discouraging anyone who says otherwise, does more harm than leaving a question open ever could. "We don't know yet" is a perfectly respectable thing for science to say. It just has to be said.
Last revised 2026-11-19